Strategic Deficits: Closing the Gap Between Intentions and The Capacity to Deliver Results

Thoughts for Boards and Executives

Introduction

Strategic deficits are common in organizations, large and small. They challenge decision making, risk management, and forward planning. Here is our working definition of strategic deficits:

“… a gap between a company’s strategic intent and the organization’s capacity to deliver results and advance the company’s performance …”

Strategic deficits are disconnects between the company’s value proposition and the realities of the business. Acme Manufacturing makes a promise to customers about a product, information, and service experience. These are promises of value, benefits, and impact for the customer, and as well as other stakeholders. Acme Manufacturing may or may not have the capacity to deliver on those promises relative to the quality of offerings, levels of service, cost/value/risk issues, and market differentiation. These deficits become strategic in nature when Acme struggles to perform against promises, when it becomes less attractive and predictable to market stakeholders. Strategic deficits can be reduced, resolved, and resettled through disciplined action. Taking care of problems associated with strategic deficits is an important matter for both management and governance. This is where economic and strategic value are created. This is also where strategic deficits threaten to destroy value for lack of attention and urgency. And this is where organizations deal with the everyday work of getting better, smarter, and faster as situations evolve. Strategic deficits are not the same as everyday operating problems. They are not basic service problems or simple business process errors. Deficits are consequential and they cause havoc with the company’s value proposition. They are likely to interfere with the quality of decision making on investments, business portfolio planning, and business adaptation in general.

Where Strategic Deficits Emerge

In our experience, strategic deficits can be diagnosed across all three elements of a company’s Strategic Agenda. Boards and executives need to look at these elements with a critical eye:

 

 

  1. Strategy Direction: Focus and Choices
    Deficits and gaps often occur in the big ideas and assumptions we make about what the company stands for and where it’s headed. Deficits may lurk in the growth, performance, and change options that are selected — or rejected.
  2. Strategy Integration: Priorities and Resouces
    Deficits occur across the capacity of the organization, including operating systems, capital, talent, scope-and-scale of the business enterprise. This is a matter of general alignment, time spans, and overall business fitness.
  3. Strategy Execution: Action and Impact
    Deficits show up on a regular basis in everyday actions, promises, time/speed, and throughput. Execution gaps receive outsized blame for strategy miscues and screw-ups. This is where gaps become more apparent and urgent.
This view through each element of strategy helps separate where deficits occur, how and why they emerge, and why they matter — more or less. Broadly, strategic deficits matter because they are consequential for stakeholders – for customers, employees, investors, suppliers, and partners. By extension, they are consequential for governing boards and executives. They demand serious consideration, discernment, and the ongoing attention of leaders at every level of the enterprise.

Understanding Strategic Deficits

Putting things in perspective, we need a basic framework that supports analysis and dialogue on strategic deficits. This helps leadership bring focus and attention to gaps that either disable plans or distract people from the everyday work of strategy direction, integration, and execution.

Consider the following:

Strategic Deficits – The Disciplined Review and Discussion
The Company’s
Strategic Agenda
Typical Deficits
and Diagnostics
Deficit Decision
and Resets Required
Strategic Direction
Focus & Choices
Assumptions and
Choice Rationale:
Are These Sound?
Affirmation, or
Reset Strategic Intent:
Keeping Things Real
Strategic Integration
Priorities & Resources
Commitments and
Balance of Effort:
Are These Realistic?
Appropriation and
Fund/Sequence Checks:
Shifting & Surging
Strategy Execution
Action & Impact
Communication and
Talent Connections:
Are Things in Sync?
Accountability and
Ownership Checks:
Methods/Systems
From Prepared and Resolved: The Strategy Framework for Growth, Performance, and Change
Disciplined Assessment of Conditions, Smart Appropriation, Robust Accountability.
Strategic deficits require honest assessments of marketplace and organizational conditions. They beg the question, do our resources match-up with our priorities? And, how have we considered the near-term and long-term implications of our model of resource appropriation? Are we clear on accountability? Are we consistent on taking care of today — and getting ready for tomorrow? And always in the conversation, leaders need to check and recheck the core premise of the company’s strategic agenda. Are we making decisions that are fully consistent and on target?

What is the Governance Story?

Strategic deficits are natural oversight concerns for boards. While there is a “gray line” between governance and management responsibilities, board leaders should be attentive to the elements of the company’s strategic agenda where deficits and gaps reside, whether active or dormant. This is clearly a board governance matter. Board leaders and members need to sense the deficits. They need to challenge strategic commitments, alternatives, and challenges in real time.

What is the Management Story?

Strategic deficits are obvious management concerns for the senior leadership team, and should press regular management review and candor on planning and decision making for everything:

  • Product Planning and Management
  • Operational Excellence and Capacity
  • Operating Systems and Control Data
  • Revenue Generation and Planning
  • Technology Investment and Control
  • Knowledge Management and Systems
  • Resource Management and Leverage
  • Transformation Themes, Experiments

Assumptions can be assessed and validated. Options can be generated, cataloged, and invested. The need for adaptation and course correction can be simulated. The internal consistency and reality testing of strategy elements can be tracked, gauged, tested and reset over time. The big ideas need continuous management review and debate. Material strategy deficits need sunlight, and management has to be the honest broker on challenges, opportunities, and alternatives.

Strategic Deficits are Meaningful.

Strategy deficits can be complex and dynamic, with a lot of contextual factors weighing in the background of understanding and exploration. Strategic deficits tip the scales on decision making and risk management, forward planning, and problem solving. The major gaps encountered with Strategy Direction, Strategy Integration, and Strategy Execution are the mutual responsibility of both management and board governance. This requires a disciplined culture of consideration.

Bottom Line Considerations

Responding to strategic deficits is a deliberate four-point exercise. ① Start with plans and strategic intent; where are we with results, progress, outcomes? ② Identify and understand the gaps, and the nature of those gaps – in strategy direction, and/or integration, and/or execution. ③ Discern the true level of urgency and importance, the consequential issues, and the forward options for improvement and resolution. ④ Frame any critical decisions that involve important start, stop, reset choices to be made and implemented, by whom, why – with solid arguments, and when. This is a reasonable standard practice for both governance and management.

On these matters of strategic deficits, the “fitness test” for management and board governance comes down to the collective will to embrace Leadership as the Influence of Attention as the model for strategy engagement. From mission to strategic agenda to results, everything matters. What are we paying attention to? What really matters? What is the proper, viable response? What is the simple, coordinated answer to these questions on resolving strategic deficits?

Challenges of Today – Options for Tomorrow

Opening the Conversations that Matter